Bus Conversion Magazine Bulletin Board

Bus Discussion => Bus Topics ( click here for quick start! ) => Topic started by: Tikvah on September 22, 2011, 04:37:12 AM



Title: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Tikvah on September 22, 2011, 04:37:12 AM
I snapped one of the shafts of my air wiper motor.  Now I need to replace the motor.  I've heard there is an electric replacement for these air units.
Am I better off to go with electric?  Where do I get a replacement, air or electric?  Any experience?

Dave


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: belfert on September 22, 2011, 05:25:33 AM
Modern cars don't have air or vacuum wipers anymore.  With air you have to worry about bad valves, air leaks, and bad seals.

Autex (www.autexacs.com (http://www.autexacs.com)) makes electric retrofit kits for many models of buses


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Joe Camper on September 22, 2011, 05:28:54 AM
Been there, still there, and never solved the issue.

No good solutions IMHO

If you go to electric you should need some kind of transmission (linkage) to connect both sides together. Prevo has a kit for electric conversion it is way way expensive.

The alternative is stay with air that is also pricey itself and performance is terrible.

I have hoped a common motor from a bone yard would make a suitable replacement and then I would simply buy 2 and run them separate off 2 switches to eliminate the linkage project...........but I have not persued that yet.

Someone had some conversion kits for sale or had a source for them and I think it was here. I had reason why i did not go that route but forget why. I think cost of those too



Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: luvrbus on September 22, 2011, 05:35:42 AM
AM Equipment in Or I believe the kit is little over 600 for the electric conversion for a MCI


good luck


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Tikvah on September 22, 2011, 05:43:54 AM
I remember driving school bus years ago and they had electric wipers, on separate switches.  I think linkage would be too difficult, but also a lot of strain on one motor.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: oldmansax on September 22, 2011, 05:44:53 AM
every truck I ever owned had air & the MCI has air. Keep 'em maintained & I don't have any problems.

TOM


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Joe Camper on September 22, 2011, 05:47:34 AM
I just called the link posted in this thread its 750 for the Prevo one.

On our bus the square mounting plate on the front of the bus that the post goes thru that the arm attaches to has screw fasteners that are FROZEN SOLID. This was another issue for me. If those panels have to be removed I will need to grind off the heads drill out the screws and re tap the threads for every single screw I could not get even 1 of them to budge.

I can access those motors relatively easily from inside the bus but never found out if I could do the change completely without having to pull the outside access off.

I think it is safe to say sticking with air would be the easier and less expensive alternative.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: belfert on September 22, 2011, 05:58:40 AM
My Dina has separate electric motors for each wiper.  I can control each wiper individually for high and low constant speed.  For intermittent wipers there is one switch for both wipers.  I would have thought all buses with electric motors would have two motors.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: blank on September 22, 2011, 06:15:11 AM
Modern cars don't have air or vacuum wipers anymore.  

  And your point? Airplanes still use Magnetos and vacuum powered flight instruments so they will still function after a complete electrical failure. The most common failure ive seen in vehicles is electrical, and on road trips its common to see the battery or alternator fail. Reading these Bus forums I see a lot of the same thing. The more systems we have that dont require electricity, the farther we can run down the road after the alternator goes south. That some of these old Buses are 50 or 60 years old and the pneumatic wipers still work should be enough to have some faith in them.

  All the Buses Ive seen with air wipers have dual air motors with seperate controls. And they are vernier, in that you can turn the knob to any speed you want infinetly. So slow its every bit like intermittent.

  
  

  


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: luvrbus on September 22, 2011, 06:22:51 AM
Electric wipers are far better than air but like Joe said you still have the linkage even the air has 2 motors,direct drive electric wiper motors are available but at a premium price and they have a clutch instead of linkage


good luck


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: lostagain on September 22, 2011, 06:30:51 AM
Air wipers work very well. It takes a little maintenance once in a while to keep them reliable. Air wipers are part of what makes a bus a bus.

JC


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: bobofthenorth on September 22, 2011, 06:44:51 AM
IMO the best two changes I made to the frenchy-bus after we bought her were a King Cruise and changing the wipers to Autex electrics.  But I'm sorry to say you absolutely have to get those plates off the front in order to do the swap.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Joe Camper on September 22, 2011, 06:53:48 AM
LOL you have a 4 year older bus than us. Used up the entire weekend uh. Welcome to the world of Prevo ownership ;D

 It is also up above the paint line so I would need to be careful about that aspect too. I do not see it happening any time soon.

What is a King Cruise.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: bobofthenorth on September 22, 2011, 07:29:27 AM
What is a King Cruise.

Brand of cruise control. 


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: TomC on September 22, 2011, 08:30:37 AM
While my older '85 Kenworth and my '77 AMGeneral bus has air wipers (the AMGenerals are going to be changed) I don't know of any commercial vehicle that are still using air.  All are electric now-and use just one electric motor for both wipers.  Good Luck, TomC


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Oonrahnjay on September 22, 2011, 11:07:08 AM
  AM Equipment in Or I believe the kit is little over 600 for the electric conversion for a MCI 

Maybe somebody could do it the "Garhawk" way.  Gary went to an "auto recycler" (I once heard a mutual friend tell Gary that he spent more time in a junk yard than a '58 Buick) and bought a wiper motor off one car and the linkage off another for his RTS.  Works a treat.  I think he said that he had less than $20 in it.  Oh, yeah - he had to make a pivot post for the "second" wiper.  Maybe that was the $600 part.   ;D

BH NC USA


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: luvrbus on September 22, 2011, 11:46:39 AM
I don't think anything came with air wipers made in the 21st Century

good luck


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: belfert on September 22, 2011, 02:50:16 PM
Modern cars don't have air or vacuum wipers anymore.  

  And your point? Airplanes still use Magnetos and vacuum powered flight instruments so they will still function after a complete electrical failure. The most common failure ive seen in vehicles is electrical, and on road trips its common to

My point is if you're choosing between a replacement air motor and a replacement electric motor I would choose electric all other things being equal.  If the electric motor requires reworking the rest of the system air may still make sense.  There has to be a good reason they don't use air or vacuum on modern vehicles.

I'm not old enough to have driven or ever been in a vehicle that had I knew didn't have electric wipers.  (One exception was an old truck that the vacuum wiper didn't work anyhow.)

If the battery or alternator fails your headlights won't work anyhow and you should stop driving.  Most all states now have laws requiring headlights when wipers are necessary.  There are a lot more people here asking how to fix or replace air wipers than asking how to fix electric wipers.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: RJ on September 22, 2011, 04:17:03 PM
Quote
There are a lot more people here asking how to fix or replace air wipers than asking how to fix electric wipers.

Brian -

That's because the vast majority of coaches found in the conversion community came from the factory with Sprague air wipers, not electric.

25 > 30 years from now, people will be asking how to fix electrics, since most new highway coaches today have gone that route.

FWIW & HTH. . .

 ;)


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: robertglines1 on September 22, 2011, 04:25:01 PM
Unless you are unhappy with the performance  fix what you have.   Did and still doing the job in allot of buses.  Is that piece mild steel? Drill center and tap put stud in and tighten. Bob


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: gus on September 27, 2011, 05:50:32 PM
I love my 4107 with 2-speed electric wipers but I sure miss those 4104 air wipers with infinite speed control.


Title: Re: Air or Electric Wiper Motor
Post by: Paladin on September 27, 2011, 06:03:06 PM
My air wipers have slight leaks when turned completely to the off position so I have to nudge them just a tad to the on position, just barely and it stops though I'm not real pleased with that possible continued source of air leakage. I can hear the air hissing even with the engine running if it's not right.
I have thought of converting to electric and that's still an option though if the air wipers can be made reliable and mostly bullet proof I'd stick with them. I haven't stayed current on this topic over the years due to other more pressing matters on the bus but I seem to recall running across someones page where they ran down the process and parts needed for rebuilding an MCI switch\valve. Can't address other brands though maybe similar or same??

Maybe this could be a topic for the magazine (if that's not where I read it to begin with!)?.